No
Emeralds are a variety of the mineral beryl, and their color is primarily due to trace amounts of chromium and sometimes vanadium. While green is the most common and characteristic color of emeralds, they can also appear in shades of blue-green or yellowish green, but pure blue emeralds do not exist naturally. The statement inaccurately suggests that emeralds can be distinctly blue, which is not supported by gemological standards.
Source: GROK-1 Validator (Grok)
AI CONSENSUS:100%NO
Profile: GEMINI Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: While most emeralds are green, their color can vary due to trace elements. Blue emeralds are extremely rare, but green is the defining characteristic. The statement implies a binary choice that isn't entirely accurate.
NO
Profile: GROK-1 Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Emeralds are a variety of the mineral beryl, and their color is primarily due to trace amounts of chromium and sometimes vanadium. While green is the most common and characteristic color of emeralds, they can also appear in shades of blue-green or yellowish green, but pure blue emeralds do not exist naturally. The statement inaccurately suggests that emeralds can be distinctly blue, which is not supported by gemological standards.
NO
Profile: SONNET-20240229 Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Emeralds are a variety of the mineral beryl that is colored green due to trace amounts of chromium and sometimes vanadium. By definition, emeralds are green gemstones. Blue beryls are called aquamarines, not emeralds.
NO
Profile: DeepSeek V3
Vote: NO
Rationale: lius ```json { "answer": "No", "confidence": 90, "rationale": "Emeralds are specifically defined as a green variety of the mineral beryl. While some beryl varieties (like aqu
Provider: Google
Profile: GEMINI Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: While most emeralds are green, their color can vary due to trace elements. Blue emeralds are extremely rare, but green is the defining characteristic. The statement implies a binary choice that isn't entirely accurate.
Provider: Grok
Profile: GROK-1 Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Emeralds are a variety of the mineral beryl, and their color is primarily due to trace amounts of chromium and sometimes vanadium. While green is the most common and characteristic color of emeralds, they can also appear in shades of blue-green or yellowish green, but pure blue emeralds do not exist naturally. The statement inaccurately suggests that emeralds can be distinctly blue, which is not supported by gemological standards.
Provider: Anthropic
Profile: SONNET-20240229 Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Emeralds are a variety of the mineral beryl that is colored green due to trace amounts of chromium and sometimes vanadium. By definition, emeralds are green gemstones. Blue beryls are called aquamarines, not emeralds.
Provider: OpenRouter
Profile: DeepSeek V3
Vote: NO
Rationale: lius ```json { "answer": "No", "confidence": 90, "rationale": "Emeralds are specifically defined as a green variety of the mineral beryl. While some beryl varieties (like aqu