No consensus
No rationale provided
Source: Unknown Validator (Unknown Provider)
AI CONSENSUS:N/ANO
Profile: SONNET-20240229 Validator
Vote: NO
Confidence: 0%
Rationale: Error: Anthropic API error: 404 Not Found - {"type":"error","error":{"type":"not_found_error","message":"model: claude-3-sonnet-20240229"},"request_id":"req_011CSqx7y6h7biDpc3UEN7RS"}
0%
NO
Profile: DeepSeek V3
Vote: NO
Confidence: 0%
Rationale: Unable to validate due to a technical issue.
0%
YES
Profile: Meta: Llama 3.3 70B Instruct Validator
Vote: YES
Confidence: 90%
Rationale: Historical records indicate that Lydia, an ancient kingdom in modern-day Turkey, is credited with introducing the first standardized gold and silver coins around 560 BCE, under the rule of King Croesus, marking a significant innovation in currency and trade.
90%
YES
Profile: OpenAI gpt-40 Validator
Vote: YES
Confidence: 90%
Rationale: Lydia, an ancient kingdom located in what is now western Turkey, is widely credited as the first civilization to mint coins as currency. This innovation is generally dated to the 7th century BCE. The Lydians used electrum, a naturally occurring alloy of gold and silver, to create these coins. While there is some debate among historians about the exact origins and timing, the consensus supports Lydia as the first to use coins in this way.
90%
NO
Profile: Claude 3 Opus Validator
Vote: NO
Confidence: 90%
Rationale: Lydia is considered one of the earliest civilizations to mint coins as currency, but not the first. The first known coins were minted in the 7th century BCE by the Lydians in Anatolia, but there is evidence that China may have minted coins even earlier, possibly as early as the late 2nd millennium BCE during the Shang Dynasty.
90%
YES
Profile: Perplexity: Sonar (OpenRouter)
Vote: YES
Confidence: 95%
Rationale: The statement that Lydia was the first civilization to mint coins as currency is widely supported by historical evidence. The earliest known coins, made of electrum (a natural alloy of gold and silver), were minted in Lydia around 650-660 BC. Ancient sources such as Herodotus credit the Lydians as the first to introduce gold and silver coinage. While there is some debate about exact dates and the involvement of neighboring regions like Ionia, Lydia is generally recognized as the origin of true coinage. Other early coinages, such as those in China and India, appeared around the same period but are considered separate developments. Thus, Lydia is credited as the first civilization to mint coins as currency in the form recognized historically[1][2][3][5].
95%
1 model excluded due to invalid response
Provider: Anthropic
Profile: SONNET-20240229 Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Error: Anthropic API error: 404 Not Found - {"type":"error","error":{"type":"not_found_error","message":"model: claude-3-sonnet-20240229"},"request_id":"req_011CSqx7y6h7biDpc3UEN7RS"}
Provider: OpenRouter
Profile: DeepSeek V3
Vote: NO
Rationale: Unable to validate due to a technical issue.
Provider: OpenRouter
Profile: Meta: Llama 3.3 70B Instruct Validator
Vote: YES
Rationale: Historical records indicate that Lydia, an ancient kingdom in modern-day Turkey, is credited with introducing the first standardized gold and silver coins around 560 BCE, under the rule of King Croesus, marking a significant innovation in currency and trade.
Provider: OpenAI
Profile: OpenAI gpt-40 Validator
Vote: YES
Rationale: Lydia, an ancient kingdom located in what is now western Turkey, is widely credited as the first civilization to mint coins as currency. This innovation is generally dated to the 7th century BCE. The Lydians used electrum, a naturally occurring alloy of gold and silver, to create these coins. While there is some debate among historians about the exact origins and timing, the consensus supports Lydia as the first to use coins in this way.
Provider: OpenRouter
Profile: Claude 3 Opus Validator
Vote: NO
Rationale: Lydia is considered one of the earliest civilizations to mint coins as currency, but not the first. The first known coins were minted in the 7th century BCE by the Lydians in Anatolia, but there is evidence that China may have minted coins even earlier, possibly as early as the late 2nd millennium BCE during the Shang Dynasty.
Provider: OpenRouter
Profile: Perplexity: Sonar (OpenRouter)
Vote: YES
Rationale: The statement that Lydia was the first civilization to mint coins as currency is widely supported by historical evidence. The earliest known coins, made of electrum (a natural alloy of gold and silver), were minted in Lydia around 650-660 BC. Ancient sources such as Herodotus credit the Lydians as the first to introduce gold and silver coinage. While there is some debate about exact dates and the involvement of neighboring regions like Ionia, Lydia is generally recognized as the origin of true coinage. Other early coinages, such as those in China and India, appeared around the same period but are considered separate developments. Thus, Lydia is credited as the first civilization to mint coins as currency in the form recognized historically[1][2][3][5].